When you think about Ed Sheeran, Marvin Gaye probably isnโt the first person who comes to mind. But maybe he should be. This week, Sheeran is defending himself in court against allegations that he ripped off Gayeโs classic song โLetโs Get it Onโ in his 2014 hit โThinking Out Loud.โ
Suggested Reading
The lawsuit is being brought by the family of Ed Townsend, a famous Black singer-songwriter who co-wrote โLetโs Get It Onโ with Gaye. Townsendโs heirs are being represented by civil rights attorney Benjamin Crump, who folks will probably recognize as the lead attorney on countless high-profile police brutality cases. Crump and the Townsend family arenโt pulling the comparisons to the 1973 song out of thin air. In his arguments before the jury, Crump pointed to a 2014 Ed Sheeran performance where the singer mashed up the two songs, noting their similarity.
โWe have a smoking gun,โ said Crump about the video.
For his part, Sheeran doesnโt deny that the songs have some similarities. In his testimony on Tuesday, Sheeran argued that all pop music builds on previous work, but that doesnโt mean he would outright steal from another artist.
โIf Iโd done what youโre accusing me of doing, Iโd be an idiot to stand on stage in front of 20,000 people and do that,โ said Sheeran, according to CNBC, referencing the 2014 mash-up.โIt is my belief that most pop songs are built on building blocks that have been freely available for hundreds of years.โ
This isnโt the first time heโs been accused of ripping off other artistsโ sounds. In 2018 Sami Chokri and Ross OโDonoghue sued Sheeran, alleging that heโd ripped off their 2015 album. Chokri and OโDonoghue lost the case, and Sheeran was awarded $1.1 million in legal fees.
The big question is, what happens if Sheeran loses this case? Well, the Townsend family wonโt be getting a payout just yet. If a jury finds Sheeran guilty of copyright, the trial will move to a second phase, where the amount of money Sheeran owes the family would be determined. For fans of Gayeโs classic song, this is definitely a trial to watch.
Straight From
Sign up for our free daily newsletter.